Skip to content
Tax disputes13 min read

Decision deeming a notice not executed: what to do

Tax decision deeming a notice not executed in Kazakhstan: e-invoices (ЭСФ) stopped, notifications to counterparties, an audit, the complaint deadline and court practice of 2026.

The LLP (ТОО) answered the notice, but the tax authority did not accept the written response and issued a decision deeming the notice not executed. Under a notice to confirm turnover, e-invoice (ЭСФ) issuance is stopped after one working day, and buyers receive notifications about their settlements with you. Under a notice on registration a tax audit is appointed. This article covers how to tell this decision from simple failure to execute, what to do in the first days, how to appeal the decision and on what grounds courts cancelled it in 2026.

What a decision deeming a notice not executed is

The Tax Code of the RK 2026 (НК РК) provides for such a decision on two notices of an informational and warning nature.

The first is the notice on registration with the tax authority following monitoring of tax registration. Under art. 107(4) of the НК РК,

"A notice is deemed not executed if the written response submitted does not contain reasons and (or) the reasons are not confirmed by documents."

The second is the notice to confirm that turnover on the sale of goods, performance of work and provision of services actually took place, following comparative control of e-invoices. Under art. 142(4) of the НК РК,

"A notice is deemed not executed if the written response submitted does not confirm the origin of the goods or the actual performance of work or provision of services under the electronic invoices stated in the notice."

The deadlines for issuing the decision differ. Under article 107 the decision is issued "within twenty working days following the day the written response is received" (art. 107(5) of the НК РК). Under article 142 the period is half as long:

"The tax authority issues a decision deeming the notice not executed within ten working days following the day the written response is received."

(art. 142(5) of the НК РК). In both cases the decision is sent to the taxpayer within two working days after it is issued.

For the notice of desk control discrepancies (art. 137 of the НК РК) the new Code does not provide for a decision deeming it not executed. A court noted this directly in one of the cases of 2026; see below.

Failure to execute a notice and deeming it not executed: the difference

These are two different situations with different consequences.

The deadline for answering a notice is set by art. 82(2) of the НК РК:

"The deadline for executing notices of an informational and warning nature is thirty working days following the day of service, unless otherwise provided by this clause. The deadline for executing a notice to confirm that turnover on the sale of goods, performance of work and provision of services actually took place is ten working days following the day of service."

NoticeDeadlineNo response filed on timeResponse filed and rejected
On registration (art. 107)30 working daysblocking of bank accounts (art. 107(7))tax audit (art. 107(6))
To confirm turnover (art. 142)10 working daysblocking of accounts and e-invoices stopped (art. 142(7))e-invoices stopped and notifications to counterparties (art. 142(6), (10))

The response must be filed on time even while the documents are still being collected: a decision deeming the notice not executed does not block the bank accounts, but silence does.

Consequences of the decision on a notice on registration

Under art. 107(6) of the НК РК,

"On a notice deemed not executed a tax audit of the taxpayer is conducted, except for a foreign company operating through an internet platform in the Republic of Kazakhstan."

The audit will concern the tax registration question stated in the notice. It is better to prepare for it immediately after receiving the decision. How we work with audits is described on the tax audit support page.

Consequences of the decision on a notice to confirm turnover

Here the consequences come faster and affect the buyers of the LLP.

E-invoice issuance is stopped. By virtue of art. 142(6) of the НК РК,

"The tax authority suspends the issuance of electronic invoices within one working day following the day the decision is issued."

Information on the suspension is published. Under art. 88(4) of the НК РК, it is posted on the internet resource of the authorised body within one working day after the decision is issued and removed from it within one working day of the date it is cancelled.

Buyers receive notifications. Under art. 142(10) of the НК РК,

"The tax authority sends a notification on the mutual settlements stated in the notice to the counterparties of a taxpayer whose notice has been deemed not executed or that has not executed the notice."

The buyers themselves may undergo a thematic audit. Under sub-clause 5) of art. 156(2) of the НК РК, it is conducted on questions of

"determining the tax obligation on mutual settlements with a taxpayer (taxpayers) in respect of which the tax authority has suspended the issuance of electronic invoices under sub-clause 1) of clause 1 of article 88 of this Code".

For a business this is the main risk: a buyer whose deductions are under threat usually stops working with the supplier before the dispute ends.

An example of the timing under article 142:

EventDeadline
Answer to the notice10 working days after service
Issuance of the decision10 working days after the response is received
Sending the decision to the LLP2 working days after issuance
E-invoice issuance stopped1 working day after issuance

E-invoice issuance is stopped on the working day after the decision is issued, while the decision itself may arrive a day later. So an LLP sometimes learns that e-invoices have been stopped before it receives the decision.

What the response must be like for the tax authority to accept it

The response is filed in free form. Under article 107 it must contain the identification data of the LLP and the tax authority, the number and date of the notice and the reasons for disagreement (art. 107(3) of the НК РК). The requirements of article 142 are the same, but the reasons must confirm that the turnover actually took place.

Clause 2 and clause 3 of article 142 diverge. Sub-clause 2) of art. 142(2) of the НК РК requires a response

"with mandatory attachment of copies of documents on the operations (transactions) and (or) on the origin of the goods, and any other documents confirming the actual performance of work or provision of services".

At the same time art. 142(3) of the НК РК provides:

"The taxpayer may attach to the written response copies of documents confirming its arguments. The tax authority may not demand documents unrelated to the breaches stated in the notice."

The documents should be attached anyway; this removes the main argument of the УГД. What to attach:

  • the contract and specifications for the e-invoices in the notice;
  • acts of work performed, delivery notes, transport documents (CMR, СНТ);
  • documents on the origin of the goods: suppliers' e-invoices, goods declarations, VAT forms on import;
  • documents on the warehouse, machinery and personnel, if the УГД refers to their absence;
  • payment orders on settlements with the buyer.

How to appeal a decision deeming a notice not executed

The decision is an administrative act. Under art. 91(1) of the Administrative Procedure Code of the RK (АППК),

"A participant in the administrative procedure may appeal an administrative act or an administrative action (inaction) not connected with the adoption of an administrative act in the administrative (pre-trial) procedure."

The complaint deadline is set by art. 92(1) of the АППК: it is filed

"no later than three months from the day the participant in the administrative procedure became aware of the adoption of the administrative act or the commission of the administrative action (inaction)."

A complaint, however, will most likely not lift the stop on e-invoices. Under the general rule of art. 96(1) of the АППК, filing a complaint suspends execution of the act, but with an exception "in other cases provided by the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan". Art. 142(8) of the НК РК calls the measures of clauses 5, 6 and 7 of that article security measures. And by virtue of art. 199(2) of the НК РК,

"Appealing the actions of officials on securing performance of the tax obligation and on enforced collection of tax debt does not suspend the application or operation of security measures and enforced collection measures."

The difference from an appeal against audit results is fundamental here: art. 84(5) of the НК РК suspends security measures only where the notice on tax audit results is appealed.

So when e-invoices are stopped it is faster to go to court with a claim and an application for interim measures. Under art. 139(2) of the АППК,

"An application for interim measures received together with the claim is considered by the judge within five working days from the day the claim is received."

After the decision is cancelled, e-invoice issuance is restored. Courts state that cancellation of the decision entails cancellation of its consequences, including the restriction on e-invoice issuance (art. 155(3) of the АППК).

Step-by-step procedure

Step 1. Identify the type of notice and the deadline

From the heading of the notice identify the article: 107 or 142. Count the working days from the day following the day of service.

Step 2. File the response on time

Even an incomplete response filed on time protects against the blocking of accounts. Send the missing documents before the deadline expires.

Step 3. On receiving the decision, check its content

Compare the e-invoices listed in the decision with the notice. Check which documents the УГД called missing and whether they relate to the breach.

Step 4. Warn key buyers

If e-invoice issuance has been stopped, tell the buyers about the dispute and give them copies of the primary documents. The buyer will need these documents if an audit on mutual settlements with you starts at the buyer.

Step 5. File a claim with an application for interim measures

When e-invoices are stopped, waiting for the decision of the higher authority is usually disadvantageous. A claim with an application for interim measures is considered faster. How such cases are handled is described in the tax disputes section.

The position of the УГД and how to rebut it

The objections of the УГД in such disputes are usually the same.

The first argument: the response does not remedy the breaches, and reconciliation acts, payment orders or other documents are not attached. This cannot be accepted. If the response contains reasons and was filed on time, the notice has been executed. The НК РК prohibits demanding documents unrelated to the breach (art. 107(3), art. 142(3)).

The second argument: the transactions show signs of being formal, the participants are related parties, the LLP has no personnel or machinery. This is a question of the reality of the transactions. In 2026 courts stated that neither the tax authority when issuing the decision nor the court when reviewing it may enter into a discussion of the validity of the transactions: this would prejudge the result of a future tax audit.

The third argument: the decision is lawful until the УГД cancels it. However, the duty to prove the lawfulness of the decision lies with the tax authority (art. 129 of the АППК). If there is no evidence, the authority bears the consequences.

Court practice of 2026

In 2026 specialised interdistrict administrative courts cancelled decisions deeming notices not executed. Most of the cases were heard under the desk control rules of the НК РК of 2017, but their conclusions apply to the new Code as well, because the prohibition on demanding unrelated documents has been kept. The conclusion of a court of first instance is not always final, so the ground must be checked against the actual circumstances of your case. Courts recovered the costs of a representative from the authority, reducing them under the reasonableness criterion.

The response was filed on time and in the proper form

Courts held a notice executed if the response was filed on time and met the requirements of the Code as to content. A refusal because the УГД disagrees with the arguments on the merits is not a ground for the decision.

Refusal because of documents unrelated to the breach

The УГД deemed a notice not executed because the LLP had not submitted reconciliation acts and payment orders. The court cancelled the decision: the tax authority may not demand such documents, and failure to prove the lawfulness of the act falls on it.

The contradiction in article 142 is interpreted in favour of the LLP

Only one of these cases was heard under the new Code. The court applied article 12 of the АППК: contradictions and ambiguities in the legislation on administrative procedures are interpreted in favour of the participant in the procedure. Since art. 142(3) calls attaching documents a right, the absence of documents does not by itself make the notice not executed.

Desk control cannot be completed under article 142

The notice was issued under the desk control rules of the НК РК of 2017, while the decision was issued under article 142 of the new Code. The court stated that there are no transitional provisions for this, and article 137 of the НК РК does not provide for a decision deeming a notice not executed. The decision was cancelled.

Cancelling the decision also cancels the e-invoice restriction

In one of the cases the court at the same time cancelled the decision deeming the notice not executed and the restriction on e-invoice issuance imposed on its basis.

Mistakes that lose the case for an LLP

  1. Not answering the notice while collecting documents. As a result the accounts are blocked, although a timely response would have prevented this.
  2. Filing only a complaint with the ДГД and waiting while e-invoice issuance is stopped. A complaint does not lift this measure.
  3. Writing general phrases about the reality of transactions in the response, without references to the specific e-invoices in the notice.
  4. Sending documents unrelated to the breach at the demand of the УГД instead of referring to the prohibition on demanding them.
  5. Not warning buyers, who then learn of the problem from a notification of the tax authority.

How we help

We work from Astana with companies across Kazakhstan. On a decision deeming a notice not executed we prepare a written response, a complaint to the ДГД or a claim with an application for interim measures, and obtain restoration of e-invoice issuance. The advance is 30%, the rest after the result. If a debt following an audit has already been issued, the article on the notice to repay the tax debt will be useful. You can describe your situation through the contact form.

Dealing with this in practice?

Send us the documents. A lawyer will check the deadlines and tell you what to do next.

Frequently asked questions

Under the НК РК 2026 such a decision is issued on two notices: on registration (art. 107) and to confirm that turnover actually took place (art. 142). There is one ground: a written response was filed, but the tax authority considers it unfounded or not confirmed by documents.

If no written response is filed on time, the tax authority blocks the bank accounts (art. 107(7) and art. 142(7) of the НК РК). If a response is filed and rejected, a decision is issued: under article 107 a tax audit is appointed, under article 142 e-invoice issuance is stopped and notifications are sent to counterparties.

Ten working days following the day of service (art. 82(2) of the НК РК). For the notice on registration the general deadline applies: thirty working days following the day of service.

A complaint to the higher authority is filed no later than three months from the day the decision became known (art. 92(1) of the АППК). It is not worth delaying: e-invoice issuance is stopped one working day after the decision is issued.

We proceed on the basis that it does not. Art. 142(8) of the НК РК calls the stop on e-invoice issuance a security measure, and art. 199(2) of the НК РК says directly that appealing such measures does not suspend them. An application for interim measures in court works faster; the judge considers it within five working days.

Art. 142(2) of the НК РК requires mandatory attachment of documents, while clause 3 of the same article calls this a right of the taxpayer. In 2026 a court interpreted this contradiction in favour of the LLP under article 12 of the АППК. It is still better to attach the transaction documents: this removes the main argument of the УГД.

Procedural deadline calculator

Which document did you receive

Last day of the term

—

Served30 working days

What must be done in time
Register or file an explanation
Legal basis
30 working days from the day following the date of service (Art. 82(2) of the Tax Code)
Discuss the deadline with a lawyer

The calculation is preliminary: weekends and public holidays of Kazakhstan are taken into account, government transfers of days off are not. A term may be suspended or extended, so a lawyer should confirm the exact date.

Read also

All articles

Related cases

All cases