Skip to content
Tax disputes9 min read

Notice of desk control discrepancies: what to do

Notice of discrepancies identified by desk control in Kazakhstan: the 30-working-day deadline, agreement and partial agreement, when a written response is prohibited, blocking of accounts and e-invoices (ЭСФ), the audit.

A notice of discrepancies identified by desk control gives the LLP (ТОО) thirty working days. In this time you need to remedy the discrepancy or explain why there is no breach. If you stay silent, on the working day after the deadline the bank accounts and e-invoice (ЭСФ) issuance are blocked. Below we cover the desk control procedure under the НК РК 2026, the ways to execute the notice, the cases where a written response is prohibited and the consequences of non-execution.

What desk control and the notice of discrepancies are

Desk control is a comparison of data without a site visit. Under art. 137(1) of the Tax Code of the RK (НК РК),

"Desk control is carried out by comparing the data contained in: 1) information held by the tax authorities, including tax forms;

  1. information of other authorised state bodies on objects of taxation and (or) objects related to taxation;

  2. information on the activity of the taxpayer (tax agent) obtained from various sources of information."

Control is carried out after the deadline for filing returns for the tax period has expired, and only within the limitation period for that period (art. 137(2) of the НК РК). A notice for a period whose limitation period has expired was issued unlawfully.

Where discrepancies are identified, the LLP receives a notice. Under sub-clause 4) of art. 82(1) of the НК РК,

"A notice of discrepancies identified by desk control contains a description of the discrepancies identified and the period in which they were identified, so that the taxpayer (tax agent) can remedy them independently or submit a written response. A notice of discrepancies identified by desk control is given to the taxpayer (tax agent) within thirty working days following the day desk control is completed"

Such a notice is not sent to a participant of horizontal monitoring (art. 137(3) of the НК РК). During a tax audit no notice is issued for the audited period either. Under art. 137(8) of the НК РК,

"During a tax audit no notice for the audited period is given to the taxpayer (tax agent), and the results of desk control are to be used in the course of the tax audit being conducted."

Deadline for executing the notice

The deadline is thirty working days following the day of service (art. 82(2) of the НК РК). With electronic delivery the day of service is the date of delivery to the web application or cabinet (sub-clause 2) of art. 51(2) of the НК РК), not the date the accountant opened the document.

How to execute the notice: three options

Under art. 137(4) of the НК РК, the following count as execution of the notice:

"1) where the taxpayer (tax agent) agrees with the discrepancies stated in the notice: remedying the identified breaches of the tax legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan by: submitting a tax return under the notice for the tax period to which the identified discrepancies relate; paying to the budget the amount of value added tax previously refunded from the budget at the taxpayer's (tax agent's) demand for a refund of value added tax, and late payment interest for each day from the date such amounts were transferred to the taxpayer (tax agent) until the day of payment; recording data in the special mobile application and (or) paying tax and social payments, for taxpayers applying the special tax regime for the self-employed; taking the actions provided by article 716 of this Code in order to move to the appropriate tax regime;

  1. where the taxpayer (tax agent) disagrees with the discrepancies stated in the notice: submitting to the tax authority that issued the notice a written response on the causes of the discrepancies that do not amount to a breach of the tax legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan (for the purposes of this article, the written response), except in the cases provided by part one of clause 6 of this article."

Part two of the same clause gives a third option: with partial agreement, one part of the discrepancy is remedied and a written response is filed on the other.

Position of the LLPWhat to doResult
Agrees in fullfile a return under the notice or pay the taxnotice executed
Disagreesfile a written response on the causes of the discrepanciesnotice executed
Agrees in partremedy one part and file a response on the restnotice executed

The requirements for the response and a sample are covered in the article on the written response to a tax notice. One point deserves separate mention: tax authorities are prohibited from demanding documents for execution of the notice (art. 137(5) of the НК РК).

When a written response cannot be filed

Part one of art. 137(6) of the НК РК prohibits a written response on deductions and VAT offset in four cases. In all of them the defect of the documents, the transaction or the counterparty has already been established by a judicial act in force or a decision of a criminal prosecution body. The full text of the rule is given in the article on the written response.

The prohibition does not apply if a court has established the actual purchase of goods, work or services. In the cases of a sham enterprise and invalid registration of the counterparty the LLP may file such a claim. Under art. 137(7) of the НК РК,

"The deadline for executing the notice is suspended when a claim is filed in court to confirm the actual purchase (receipt) of goods, work or services in the cases stated in sub-clauses 3) and 4) of clause 6 of this article."

A copy of the ruling accepting the claim must be submitted to the tax authority. The suspension runs from the day that ruling is issued until the final judicial act enters into force.

What happens if the notice is not executed

Under art. 137(9) of the НК РК, where the notice is not executed

"2) outgoing operations on the bank accounts of a taxpayer (tax agent) not stated in sub-clause 1) of this clause are suspended within one working day following the day the deadline for executing the notice expires;

  1. the taxpayer's issuance of electronic invoices is suspended within one working day following the day the deadline for executing the notice expires."

Blocking on this ground covers all outgoing operations, not the amount of the discrepancy. How to lift each measure is covered in the articles on the order suspending outgoing operations and on the decision suspending e-invoice issuance.

In addition, the tax authority may appoint an audit. Under art. 137(10) of the НК РК,

"To confirm the reliability of the causes set out in the written response, or where the notice is not executed within the deadline set by this Code, the tax authority may conduct a tax audit on the discrepancies identified by desk control."

Can the УГД refuse to accept the response

Under the НК РК of 2017 the tax authority issued a decision deeming a notice to remedy breaches not executed. Article 137 of the new Code does not provide for such a decision. A written response under art. 137(4) is itself execution of the notice. If the УГД doubts the arguments, its tool is named in clause 10: a tax audit.

A court confirmed this in 2026. The notice had been issued under the desk control rules of the old Code, and the УГД issued a decision deeming it not executed under article 142 of the new Code. The court cancelled the decision and stated that article 137 of the НК РК does not provide for a decision deeming a notice not executed, and that there are no transitional provisions for completing desk control under the rules of comparative control. The conclusion of a court of first instance is not always final, so the ground must be checked against the actual circumstances of your case.

How desk control differs from comparative control

Comparative control of e-invoices is regulated separately, by articles 141 and 142 of the НК РК. Under it the LLP receives a different notice: to confirm that turnover actually took place, with a deadline of ten working days. And only under it may the tax authority issue a decision deeming the notice not executed. So first check the name of the notice and the article it refers to: the deadline and the consequences depend on this. More in the article on the notice to confirm turnover on e-invoices.

Step-by-step procedure

Step 1. Record the date of service and the last day of the deadline

Take a screenshot of the cabinet showing the delivery date and count thirty working days.

Step 2. Check whether the УГД was entitled to send the notice

Check the period of the discrepancy against the limitation period. Check whether a tax audit is under way for that period.

Step 3. Go through each discrepancy

For each discrepancy decide whether to remedy it or explain it. If the ground is one from art. 137(6), do not file a response; remedy the discrepancy or file a claim to confirm the actual purchase.

Step 4. Execute the notice on time

File an additional return, a written response, or both. Keep confirmation of the filing date.

Step 5. Prepare for an audit

If the response concerns large amounts, collect the primary documents in advance. Under art. 137(10) the tax authority may check the arguments of the response.

Mistakes in executing the notice

  1. Missing the deadline while waiting for documents from a counterparty.
  2. Filing a response where art. 137(6) prohibits it.
  3. Submitting documents at the demand of the УГД although demanding them is prohibited.
  4. Not checking the limitation period for the period of the discrepancy.
  5. Agreeing with the whole discrepancy although only part of it is disputable.

How we help

We work from Astana with companies across Kazakhstan. We analyse the desk control notice, prepare a written response or an additional return, and support you through the audit if the УГД appoints one. The advance is 30%, the rest after the result. More on the tax audit support page. You can leave a request through the form.

Dealing with this in practice?

Send us the documents. A lawyer will check the deadlines and tell you what to do next.

Frequently asked questions

Thirty working days following the day the notice is served (art. 82(2) of the НК РК). The deadline is suspended if the LLP (ТОО) has filed a court claim to confirm the actual purchase of goods, work or services in the cases stated in sub-clauses 3) and 4) of art. 137(6) of the НК РК.

If you agree, remedy the discrepancy, for example file a tax return under the notice. If you disagree, file a written response on the causes of the discrepancies. If you agree in part, remedy one part and file a response on the other (art. 137(4) of the НК РК).

Within one working day after the deadline, outgoing operations on the bank accounts and e-invoice issuance are suspended (art. 137(9) of the НК РК). In addition, the tax authority may conduct a tax audit on the discrepancies (art. 137(10) of the НК РК).

Article 137 of the НК РК 2026 does not provide for such a decision: the written response is execution of the notice. To check the arguments of the response the tax authority may appoint a tax audit (art. 137(10) of the НК РК).

When the expenses and VAT offset are based on documents and transactions that a court or a criminal prosecution body has found to be fictitious, invalid or made with a sham enterprise (art. 137(6) of the НК РК). In this case the notice is executed only by remedying the discrepancy.

No. During a tax audit no notice is issued for the audited period, and the results of desk control are used in the course of the audit (art. 137(8) of the НК РК).